Star Wars 

I saw the new one yesterday. It was good; it was not great. Aside from the first ~15 minutes (which need serious reworking), it would’ve been a fine end if we hadn’t had The Last Jedi first. TLJ was stellar, and TRoS walks back half of what made it great.

Also, in case The Force Awakens didn’t make it clear, Abrams is a heavy recycler, whereas Johnson seems to have really understood what made the original trilogy great and put a lot of that into a new, modern story.


Star Wars 

Also, more cynically: it sure seems like Johnson is a braver filmmaker, while Abrams seems pretty afraid of Star Wars fans. Nerfing Rose was probably TRoS’s biggest sin, on multiple levels.

Sign in to participate in the conversation is a server for folks who live in the Portland, OR region. Registration is by invitation only and you can receive an invitation by contacting a member or emailing You must abide by our Code of Conduct.

Hosted at Donations gratefully accepted via LiberaPay